Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Dulcius Ex Asperis :: Through Difficulty, Sweetness

This is a poem written by my family for my mother on the occasion of her graduating with her Ed. D.


Divinity graced humanity with the aweful responsibility of imaging the Creator.
From death to life by Holy birth and because of a true King reigning,
She fulfills her Creator's design.

Two people meet,
Three children born.

Moments of joy and laughter,
Moments of tears and sorrow.
Felt in depth of heart, seen in movement of hand, heard in words to us.
A family marked by God's "charis" alone.

Faithful care,
Endless song,
Chaste wisdom,
Not perfection but grace.

Life passes sweetly,
Now we are thirteen.

Stories. Of the classroom, or the mall, of people and studies.
These things could only happen to Nana and no one else.
She writes them and lives them. No regrets.

When pen and paper meet,
No words are chaff in wind.
Each is carefully chosen,
A striking marriage of heart and head.

The treasure hidden deep inside,
The sweet breath of grace,
Where prayers and tears once reside,
Joy outpours to fill this place.

A switch, light
A channel of power
A prayer, life
A channel of grace

With 'Classic' drink the eyes roll back.
When it's time to laugh, no sound...just joy!

Joy in beautiful relationship,
Courage in example.
Gratitude overflows.
Only a gift of such magnitude could come from above.

An Aspen meets the flame,
Then thrives, and blooms.
Strength overlaid with gentle kindness.

The "beloved" apostle ignorantly bowed down,
And the messenger of YHWH pointedly exclaimed "Worship God!"
We look at her life, and like the messenger we don't see her.
But an exclamation: "Worship God!"
An arrow that precisely points to the One who crafted it.


Saturday, August 6, 2011

Redemptive History :: Genesis and John

In Genesis the story begins. God creates everything and he creates it all good. “God saw all that he had made, and it was very good,” and that included the pinnacle of creation which was mankind created in the very image of their creator. In Genesis 3 mankind represented by Adam rejects the sovereignty and rulership of God and goes his own way bringing about great pain for all of creation. Sin and death enter the picture and now creation becomes marred and tainted. It is no longer very good. And so God’s work to bring about a reversal of the curse, sin and death and all that came with it, begins. “And I will put enmity between you and the woman and between your offspring and hers; he will crush your head, and you will strike his heel.” But then a downward spiral of wickedness begins from Gen. 3 to Gen. 11. It seems the movement of Genesis 1-2 from darkness to light is now reversed and moving back towards utter darkness.

The creator God had a plan though and he sovereignly calls a man to leave his home and go to Canaan and suddenly there is a small flicker of light—hope—which enters the story. Then comes a promise—a promise to reverse the curse. Curse which dominated the language of Genesis 3-11 is now overwhelmed by the language of blessing in Genesis 12.2-3. “I will make you into a great nation, and I will bless you; I will make your name great, and you will be a blessing. I will bless those who bless you, and whoever curses you I will curse; and all peoples on earth will be blessed through you.” From barrenness and deadness—the womb of Sarah—life comes. A nation is born—the nation to spread the light of the glory of God to all the nations. But they fail, miserably, and it appears as though the curse is once again winning the day. Sure there are ups and downs. The days of King David are quite glorious at times but never as God intended for the nation. Finally the nation goes into permanent exile for hundreds of years and hope seems all but gone. But the hope of Messiah and eternal blessing remains. Why? Because the creator God always fulfills his promises. When will the Messiah come? When will the kingdom come? When will curse finally be reversed? When will God fulfill his promise to bless the world?

Now we all know where the story goes from there. But I want us to think about it in the way that John presents it to us in his gospel. He starts at creation. “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was with God in the beginning. Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made. In him was life, and that life was the light of all mankind. The light shines in the darkness and the darkness has not overcome it.” Interesting. What is John doing? He takes us back to creation. But not just with how he starts his gospel but also the imagery that is evoked by the language. The vocabulary as well as themes of light and darkness scattered throughout the gospel create a fragrance of creation for the reader. He also carefully chooses events from Jesus life to show that he is sovereign over his creation. He is the creator God. And then the final miracle that John records for us, before the account of the cross and the final week of Jesus life, is a miracle which begins to strike at the heart of the curse. Lazarus is dead and Jesus brings him back to life. “I am the resurrection and the life. The one who believes in me will live, even though they die; and whoever lives by believing in me will never die.” So then John takes the last half of the gospel to spell out the final week of Jesus life. And on the sixth day of that week Jesus is brought before the crowds and Pilate announces “Here is the man.” I don’t think it is a coincidence that John just happened to select these words from Pilate on this occasion. John has been sitting on and thinking about the story of Jesus now for 50 plus years. So everything is carefully chosen and intentional. The sixth day of creation was marked by the creation of mankind the first Adam. The sixth day of the Passion Week is marked by Pilate’s presentation of the one true Man—the second Adam, the Son of Man—to the world. And the decision of the world is to crucify him. Now interestingly, John does not include a lot of details about Jesus actual death on the cross. But, there is one statement by Jesus that John was sure to include—“It is finished.” The echoes of creation from Genesis 1 are unmistakable. “God saw all that he had made, and it was very good. And there was evening, and there was morning—the sixth day. Thus the heavens and the earth were completed in all their vast array. By the seventh day God had finished the work he had been doing; so on the seventh day he rested from al his work.” And now Jesus would also rest on the seventh day after his work was completed. John makes it very clear that it was the Sabbath—“A special Sabbath.”

And then we come to chapter 20—John’s chapter where his account of Jesus resurrection is contained. And how does he begin his retelling of the resurrection story? “Early on the first day of the week…” And then in the middle of the chapter when the scene in the narrative changes, but it is obvious to the reader that it is still the same day, John once again punctuates this idea—“On the evening of that first day of the week.” He does not want his readers to miss it. Jesus resurrection is marking something major. It is the beginning of something new. Jesus has conquered death. Death no longer has the upper hand. The curse has been reversed and new creation is on the horizon. Jesus resurrection is the firstfruits of what is to come. New creation has been inaugurated. And so He commissions his people to go out and live in the reality of what the new creation will bring for the world. “Peace be with you! As the Father has sent me, I am sending you.” But his people are not left alone for the task. The one who is the guarantee of what is to come in the future is given to the disciples—“he breathed on them and said, receive the Holy Spirit.”

And so this is where we find ourselves in the story of redemption. We are in the overlap between the resurrection of the Messiah, the Son of God, and what it initiated, and the final outcome of what the resurrection means for all believers and for the world—the inheritance of the New Heavens and New Earth. And so we look forward to that day and anticipate that day with the way we live our lives. Fittingly John pens for us in the book of Revelation what that day is going to look like, and interestingly it is a wedding scene. What is being wedded? Heaven and earth. What the fall and curse ripped apart is once again joined. God’s realm and man’s realm is once again reunited and becomes one. “Look! God’s dwelling place is now among the people, and he will dwell with them. They will be his people, and God himself will be with them and be their God…He who was seated on the throne said, “I am making everything new!”

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

New Perspectives

I am hoping to do a more extended future post with some thoughts on the New Perspectives on Paul. However, I would like to just start by making a brief comment at this point to get us thinking. Today, the charge against Augustine, Luther, Calvin, etc. is that they adapted Paul's own words to fit their situations (cultural context) and thinking; And, they were creative in doing so. I am wondering how contemporary scholars are able to make this claim and excuse themselves from the very same accusation. Obviously, everyone is affected by their culture. Duh! The question is, who is doing a better job of recognizing all that is affecting them and able to read a text, i.e. Romans, without their cultural 'shades' distorting what 'Saint Paul Really Said'? At this point I am speculating that apathetic, antinomian, gospel proclamation without kingdom living Christianity is affecting the way some of these guys are reading Paul. Now, that does not necessarily mean that they are wrong. But, could it be that the claim they are making against Augustine, Luther, and Calvin, could just as easily be made against them? Or, is their a different situation (cultural context) that is affecting the way NPP guys are reading Paul? Clearly, 'nobody respectable' intentionally misreads an author. But, well-intentioned misreadings do happen.

Thursday, November 25, 2010

A Serious Call to Students and Pastors to Get and Keep the Biblical Languages

Posted by John Reuther on November 23, 2010

One of the greatest joys of my Bible College and Seminary training was the study of Hebrew and Greek. I have fond memories of some fantastic, effective, and excited professors. Well do I remember the 8 AM wake-up calls of our Hebrew Drill-Sergeant! (Oh, here he comes……it’s too early for this…..ugh). These professors instilled in me a love of the biblical languages and the realization that all the real gold is found in our knowledge and use of the languages. As a pastor, it is a constant challenge to keep up the rudiments of Greek and Hebrew because of the press of pastoral labors. But my training and their faithful teaching keeps me pressing on.

I want to urge all RBS students, as well as all theological students and aspirants to the Christian ministry, to delve into the languages. You have a great interest in theological studies and this is good. But do not neglect the devoted pursuit of the languages. I encourage my fellow pastors to do the same if you have not taken any courses in Greek and/or Hebrew yet. And if you are, like me, one much in need of devoting some time each week to sharpening these language tools, I urge you to do it. For all of us, this exhortation of Martin Luther says it all.

Martin Luther (1483-1546): On the Importance of the Biblical Languages.

“And let us be sure of this, we will not long preserve the gospel without the languages. The languages are the sheath in which this sword of the Spirit is contained; they are the casket in which this jewel is enshrined; they are the vessel in which this wine is held; they are the larder in which this food is stored; and, as the gospel itself points out, they are the baskets in which are kept these loaves and fishes and fragments. If through our neglect we let the languages go (which God forbid!), we shall……. lose the gospel….

Experience too has proved this and still gives evidence of it. For as soon as the languages declined to the vanishing point, after the apostolic age, the gospel and faith and Christianity itself declined more and more…… On the other hand, now that the languages have been revived, they are bringing with them so bright a light and accomplishing such great things that the whole world stands amazed and has to acknowledge that we have the gospel just as pure and undefiled as the apostles had it, that it has been wholly restored to its original purity, far beyond what it was in the days of St. Jerome and St. Augustine…….

Yes, you may say, but many of the fathers were saved and even became teachers without the languages. That is true. But how do you account for the fact that they so often erred in the Scriptures?….. Even St. Augustine himself is obliged to confess…… that a Christian teacher who is to expound the Scriptures must know Greek and Hebrew in addition to Latin. Otherwise, it is impossible to avoid constant stumbling; indeed, there are plenty of problems to work out even when one is well-versed in the languages.

There is a vast difference therefore between a simple preacher of the faith and a person who expounds the Scripture, or, as St. Paul puts it, a prophet. A simple preacher (it is true) has so many clear passages and texts available through translations that he can know and teach Christ, lead a holy life, and preach to others. But when it comes to interpreting Scripture, and working with it on your own, and disputing with those who cite it incorrectly, he is unequal to the task; that cannot be done without languages. Now there must always be such prophets in the Christian church who can dig into Scripture, expound it, and carry on disputations. A saintly life and right doctrine are not enough. Hence the languages are absolutely and altogether necessary in the Christian church, as are the prophets or interpreters; although it is not necessary that every Christian or every preacher be such a prophet, as St. Paul points out 1 Corinthians 12 and Ephesians 4……

Since it becomes Christians then to make good use of the Holy Scriptures as their one and only book and it is a sin and a shame not to know our own book or to understand the speech and words of our God, it is a still greater sin and loss that we do not study languages, especially in these days when God is offering and giving us men and books and every facility and inducement to this study, and desires his Bible to be an open book. Oh how happy the dear fathers would have been if they had had our opportunity to study the languages and come thus prepared to the Holy Scriptures! What great toil and effort it cost them to gather up a few crumbs, while we with half the labor – yes, almost without any labor at all – can acquire the whole loaf! Oh how their effort puts our indolence to shame! Yes, how sternly God will judge our lethargy and ingratitude!

Here belongs also what St. Paul calls for in 1 Corinthians 14, namely, that in the Christian church all teachings must be judged. For this a knowledge of the language is needful above all else. The preacher or teacher can expound the Bible from beginning to end as he pleases, accurately or inaccurately, if there is no one there to judge whether he is doing it right or wrong. But in order to judge one must have a knowledge of the languages; it cannot be done in any other way. Therefore, although faith and the gospel may indeed be proclaimed by simple creatures without a knowledge of languages, such preaching is flat and tame; people finally become weary and bored with it, and it falls to the ground. But where the preacher is versed in the languages, there is a freshness and vigor in his preaching, Scripture is treated in its entirety, and faith finds itself constantly renewed by a continual variety of words and illustrations. Hence, Psalm 129 likens such Scriptural studies to a hunt, saying to the deer God opens the dense forests; and Psalm 1 likens them to a tree with a plentiful supply of water, whose leaves are always green.”

Martin Luther, “To the Councilmen of All Cities in Germany That They Establish and Maintain Christian Schools,” in Luther’s Works, ed, W. Brandt and H. Lehman (Philadelphia: Muhlenberg Press, 1962) 357-366.

Cited in Gary D. Pratico and Miles V. Van Pelt, Basics of Biblical Hebrew (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2001) 118-120.

Pastor John Reuther – Lumberton, New Jersey

Saturday, September 11, 2010

Grace and Community

I would like to underscore 2 things; Grace and Community. In the last 2 years, I have seen the grace of Christ come alive in the works of his saints, specifically at CBC, And I have been challenged to consider what church really is. So first, God’s grace, which exploded on the scene when Christ came to earth, is now being manifested in his chosen people the church. “The word became flesh and made his dwelling among us. We have seen his glory, the glory of the one and only Son, who came from the Father, full of grace and truth (John 1.14).” Because of Christ-dominated or I could say grace-dominated believers at Colonial, God’s grace has become more real to me these last 2 years. From the faithful prayers of a dear saint(she introduced herself to me when I first moved down here and on numerous occasions has approached me at church and told me that she was praying for me), she has probably spent more time on her knees in the last month than I have in the last 10 years, to a sacrificial homeowner allowing me to live with him for a fraction of what he should charge me, to the generosity of a single woman giving me her second car for a dollar when it was worth who knows how much more than that, to the loving confrontation of a professor at the seminary when I really needed it, to a family having a burden for our community of believers and starting what we now call grace supplies, to the philosophy of grace giving, to the text saturated preaching, to the many families that have opened up their homes to me while I have been here. And, the grace list goes on. These are testimonies of God’s grace at work in the local body of believers in VB. Praise God for a grace church.

The second thing is community. If the church is to be marked by unity AND love for Christ and for each other, then what does that look like on a week to week basis? Is church a building we go to or a community of brothers and sisters that we laugh with, cry with, pray with, sing with, confront, exhort, weep, and rejoice with. Through conversations with friends and professors at the seminary as well as conversations with believers and just watching the body of Christ grow I have been challenged to read and reread the New Testament asking the question: what did the church really look like in the first century and how should it look today? Yes, culture changes but essential components transcend time and culture. Christ prays in John 17 that we would be one just as He and the Father are one. Does that become a reality through casual relationships and once a week interaction? Heb. 3.12-13 “See to it, brothers and sisters, that none of you has a sinful unbelieving heart that turns away from the living God. But encourage one another daily, as long as it is called “Today,” so that none of you may be hardened by sin’s deceitfulness. We have come to share in Christ!” The lone ranger mentality is out when it comes to true Christianity. We pursue Christ together. We seek his kingdom together. We persevere in the faith together. So, through conversations and watching different believers live out true Christian community I have realized more and more that we must be the church for each other. And what is the main thing that the church does for each other? We speak to each other in ways that help us not be deceived by the allurements of sin. We speak to each other in ways that cause us to have hearts of faith in the superior value of Christ over all things. We fight to maintain each other's faith, by speaking words that point people to the truth and value of Jesus. Unbelief means failing to rest in Jesus as our greatest treasure. Helping each other believe means showing people reasons why Jesus is more to be desired and trusted and loved than anything else. Jesus is not a vaccination that we take at one point in our lives and then forget about. God does not want his Son to be forgotten like a vaccination, but celebrated daily as the greatest treasure in the universe. And as believers, we are here to help each other pursue that end.

Hallelujah, All we have is Christ. Hallelujah, Jesus is our life.

(Some of my thoughts under my second point come from a Piper sermon.)

Saturday, August 7, 2010

A Model of Repentance from Rev. 2

Reviewing the letters of Revelation this afternoon. The proscribed errors and the prescribed solutions. Jesus's prescription for the Ephesian church seems the most universal of all.

Remember therefore from where you have fallen; repent, and do the works you did at first. (2.4)

Three steps: 1) Remember from where you have fallen, 2) Repent, 3) Return to the first works. The prescriptions for the other churches include things like being faithful unto death (Smyrna, Thyatira) and buying treasure from Jesus (3.18) (which is the most unique and abstract of the of the prescriptions). But the most programmatic and typical seems to be the one given to Ephesus.
1) Remember. What does a mountain climber see when he has fallen? Looking up he can see where he was, and this sight stirs a desire to return. There is the depression of knowing he was once there, and must re-step his steps; but there is also the pressing sense that he was once there, and can be again. This assumes he is an actual mountain climber who wants to climb the mountain. Those out for a stroll who happened to climb part of the mountain because the trail happened to go that way are unlikely, having fallen, to continue that direction. The casual hiker looks up and feels only stupidity for having fallen down the mountain he didn't want to climb in the first place.
But the Christian wants to climb, and so desire and remorse, not stupidity, is stirred up in him when he looks back up. And even more so by the fact that it was his own careless disregard and waywardness that caused the fall, and not some loose rock he happened to step on. It was no accidental fall; he had in some way chosen it (though he could not have had the pain and bruising and eventual length of it in mind when he made the choice). So he 2) Repents of the cursed choice that has brought him low. Of course the repentance means he thinks evil of the choice; he turns the choice over in his heart, despising it from every angle and shoving insults and cuss words into it like prayer slips in the Western Wall. But to a greater degree his repentance consists in a simple resolution not to make again the same choice. This second part is really more valuable than the first. He can insult and cram full the choice until it's nothing but a wad of paper vibrating with expletives, but as often as he makes the choice he shows it to be his master. He must resolve not to do it again, and the most sure resolution not to do it again is the act of not doing it again. A mere internal resolution is only another passing insult if it is not acted out. A resolution indeed is a resolution in deed.
Which makes the third step: 3) Return to the first works. Instead of the work that caused the fall (or more accurately all the works that caused all the inches of the fall, because the fall was probably more like a tumble than a cliff-drop) do the "first works." In this context, the works of love (2.4). (It looks like these are works of love for each other and/or Christ, or works of love for Christ through love for others; cf. Matt. 25.45; 1 Jn 4.7). No belaboring the repentance in the first sense. No prescription of wallowing or self-flagellation for the shame of the act(s). The best repentance is not hatred of sin but acts of righteousness.

We see the hill where we once stood and long to be again
A quiet curse we whisper on our choice of knowing sin
And glare in hatred up the skids where tumbled bodies ran
Then turn to do the works we did back when we first began

Sunday, July 4, 2010

The God of Fun

I would love to get your thoughts on this.

http://conservativechristianity.wordpress.com/2010/07/01/the-god-of-fun/

The God of Fun
By David
When we think about the affections, we are thinking about what our hearts value: their desires, inclinations, dispositions, and tastes.

One value which we seem to seek to shape in our children is the value of fun. Fun is an unquestioned, undisputed right of children. When we think of children, it seems we regard fun as the greatest good.

Fun, fun, fun. Learning at school must be fun, and curriculi are now judged on how much fun they make the learning process. School holidays must be fun, and a veritable industry of holiday activities and entertainments now exists. Sports must be fun, and it is the supposed inherent fun of beating others at games that I suppose makes sports so central to our culture. Eating breakfast must have fun pictures on the box, fun toys inside and fun sugary food to boot. Observe the mountain of toys in the average Western child’s bedroom. What he or she needs most is fun, and Mom and Dad will buy it. Brushing our teeth must be done with fun-shaped toothbrushes, and fun-tasting toothpaste. Bathing must include toys, so that fun may be had in the act of cleaning oneself. Pajamas must have fun pictures on them, and so must the blankets. And at the top of this fun-list is television. Television producers have been masters at satisfying and creating the appetite for fun. Immediate, interesting, amusing, startling, comical, rambunctious images keep the fun going. And a child without a steady diet of TV has no fun, you see.

Perhaps I am not exaggerating when I say that our culture regards fun as the greatest good when it comes to children. Fun is the supreme goal for children. I am not sure at what point this supreme value loses its centrality, but at some point, the bored young humans are introduced to the truth, “Life’s not all about fun, you know!” This cynical statement is a rather heartless and violent introduction to reality, since nothing in all the child’s existence could have revealed this fact. From the rising of the sun to the going down of the same, the child is to have fun.

I don’t know all the origins of this fun-as-supreme-value ethic. I suspect much of it began with Romanticism’s idealising of the child as the paragon of innocence and virtue, and therefore thinking it deserving of a childhood of uncomplicated play. However, as a parent and pastor, I am concerned with how this idea will shape the religious imagination of my children, and the children in my congregation. I’m worried about how teaching our children to love fun above all else will become a major stumbling-block to their worship. Because the fun-ethic has not escaped church life.

Observe what we ask our children when they come out of Sunday School. “Did you have fun?” Indeed, that’s what we expect from our children’s programmes: fun. The materials must be colourful and fun to look at. The activities must be interesting and fun to do. Fun games need to be played. The songs must be full of movement, comical gestures and catchy tunes. They must be fun to sing. The lessons must be funny, zany and fun to listen to. And we judge them a success if our children return with the ultimate value statement: “That was fun!” When someone has a talent for fun-making, we remark, “He’s really good with the children!” Yes, if a child thinks church is fun, they will like it. And hopefully, we reason, they’ll become Christians.

The problem is this: at what point, and in what way, do we graduate our children to the understanding that God is not fun? The fear of the Lord is not a “fun” experience. Singing “Holy, Holy, Holy” is not fun. One thinks of words like sobriety, awe, hope, or adoration to describe the experience, but fun is not one of them. Preparing sermons is not fun. I enjoy doing it, and am greatly enriched by the intense study of God’s Word. But it isn’t fun, like Tetris, or playing fetch with my dog. Nor is listening to a patient explanation of God’s Word. Illuminating, encouraging, disturbing, challenging, provocative, perhaps, but not fun. Prayer is not fun. Intense concentration, focus and meditation on God’s revealed character is penetrating, revealing, satisfying, exhilarating and exhausting. But it is not fun. And the Lord’s Supper is never fun. Daunting, intimidating, heart-rending, welcoming, refreshing, but never fun. Worship is not fun, and yet we think fun is the key to creating little worshippers.

We face several large obstacles to overcome the fun-ethic.

First, our culture simply takes it for granted. It is the way we do things. Therefore, to question it is to disturb the way the machine runs.

Second, pragmatism guides our methods. We want our children to be in church, and to worship, so we figure that fun ought to be brought in to hook them on church. This is not different from using rock and pop music, promising your best life now, or offering a car raffle in the foyer of the church. We think that ends justify means.

Third, we create and sustain this appetite in so many ways outside of church. I grew up in the fun culture, and pass it on without thinking. But what did children do before the world smothered them with its overflowing, laughing box of fun in the last two centuries? They found things to do and make. They learned things. They helped at home. Where they could, they read. They played music with their families. They worshipped at church. And they played. In other words, they were little humans preparing for their adult lives. We, on the other hand, consciously look for ways to entertain and amuse our children, to keep the fun levels high.

If the affections of our children seek fun above all else, they have inordinate affections. And it is up to those who shape children to think about how to shape what they value.

We are always shaping our children’s affections, by what we love, and what we expect from them. If we expect them to not only play, but work and serve, they learn that fun is not central to life. If we insist that they must learn, even when that learning is not fun, we teach them what learning is like in real life. If we send them out to amuse themselves with sticks and rocks and mud and dead birds, like children always have, we shape them to find and create enjoyment, not wait for it to be given to them. And more to the heart of the matter of the affections: if we teach them to be motivated by the truth, goodness and beauty of things and actions, we teach them to value things for what they are, not merely for what they supply. If we remove fun as the governing arbiter of value, we prepare them to love things for what they are worth, not merely for what kind of ephemeral thrill they provide. If we insist that they learn to live with their boredom with worship, we teach them to postpone their judgement on what they do not yet understand. In other words, we prepare them to be worshippers, not consumers.

And perhaps we will see them still worshipping in twenty years.

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Packer on preaching

From the T4G blog:

A sermon is “an applicatory declaration, spoken in God’s name and for his praise, in which some part of the written Word of God delivers through the preacher some part of its message about God and godliness in relation to those whom the preacher addresses.” (J.I. Packer, “Truth and Power: The Place of Scripture in the Christian Life,” chapter 5: Mouthpiece for God, page 162)

Thursday, February 18, 2010

A New Kind of Christian

http://shar.es/maWVG

Hey Guys,

The link above is for a tremendous article by Kevin DeYoung reviewing McLaren's book "A New Kind of Christian." Read part one to get his summary of the book.

Two quick thoughts:

1. Theology is important...really important. I have read a few parts of McLaren's book and it is very easy to see why his writing appeals to people. While they are enticing thoughts, they are almost entirely misrepresentations of orthodox theology and shoddy exegesis of the Biblical texts.

2. I was hit by the weight of this error after reading the review. There are thousands of people who have bought into this misrepresentation of the Gospel. McLaren makes Jesus out to be a lot of things, but refuses to make him our sin-bearer. In short, a new kind of Christian loves the wrong Jesus.

I would love to read your thoughts about this.

AB

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Considering Vocational Ministry

I came across this in one of the letters from C.S. Lewis in A Severe Mercy. He's talking to Sheldon Vanauken (the autobiographer), who is considering both Christianity and switching his field of study from history to theology. I think these thoughts are particularly applicable to us as we are all right now determining our life's work.

Lewis to Vanauken:

"We must ask three questions about the probable effect of changing your research subject to something more Theological.

(1.) Wd. it be better for your immediate enjoyment? Answer, probably but not certainly, Yes.

(2.) Wd. it be better for your academic career? Answer, probably No. You wd. have to make up in haste a lot of knowledge which wd. not be v. easily digested in the time.

(3.) Wd. it be better for your soul? I don't know. I think there is a great deal to be said for having one's deepest spiritual interest distinct from one's ordinary duty as a student or professional man. St. Paul's job was tent-making. When the two coincide I shd. have thought there was a danger lest the natural interest in one's job and the pleasures of gratified ambition might be mistaken for spiritual progress and spiritual consolation; and I think clergymen sometimes fall into this trap. Contrariwise, there is a danger that what is boring and repellent in the job may alienate one from the spiritual life. And finally, someone has said 'None are so unholy as those whose hands are cauterised with holy things; sacred things may become profane by becoming matters of the job. You now want spiritual truth for her own sake; how will it be when the same truth is also needed for an effective footnote in your thesis? In fact, the change might do good or harm. I've always been glad myself that Theology is not the thing I earn my living by. On the whole, I'd advise you to get on with your tent-making. The performance of a duty will probably teach you quite as much about God as academic Theology wd. do. Mind, I'm not certain: but that is the view I incline to.

[Second Letter] Look: the question is not whether we should bring God into our work or not. We certainly should and must: as MacDonald says 'All that is not God is death.' The question is whether we should simply (a.) Bring Him in in the dedication of our work to Him, in the integrity, diligence, and humility with which we do it or also (b.) Make His professed and explicit service our job. The A vocation rests on all men whether they know it or not; the B vocation only on those who are specially called to it. Each vocation has its peculiar dangers and peculiar rewards. Naturally, I can't say which is yours. When I spoke of danger to your academic career in a change of subject I was thinking chiefly of time. If you can get an extra year, it would be another matter."

This directly addresses at least my position. I have for a long time been planning to go into the ministry of some sort. Funny, I've never pictured myself as a pastor, at least not that I remember. I just pictured "gospel ministry" in some vague way, as if I would make my living reading the Bible and having conversations on the street. The more I've seen, the more the term "ministry" has included. Even a "secular" job. If you can be called a "missionary" for going to Turkey and running a sign-making shop and sharing the gospel when possible, can you not be called a "minister" for running a lawn care business in Dover and sharing the gospel when possible? The NT doesn't talk about being a pastor as a vocation does it? Apostles, traveling founders of the church receiving pay ("the ox is worthy…" etc.) yes. But pastors? I imagine that the elders appointed in churches were supported very little by the lay people. So the hard distinction of "minister" and "layperson" that refers to the positions vocationally must have come with the advent of (sufficiently) paid ministerial positions.

Not that this is bad: having vocational ministers is a luxury and great benefit to the churches. It must be an advantage to have pastors who can spend all their time working on improving and strengthening the church rather than thirty or forty percent. So it can't be a question of whether we should have vocational ministers or not; if we can have them we should have them. The question for us (or maybe just me) is then, should we be them? I think we should consider two things from Lewis's letters: 1) Can we handle the difficulties he mentions in question #3? Would it be better for our souls not to be vocational ministers? 2) Are we called?

Has someone written something on a theology of calling? It would be good to read on call in the NT.

Monday, December 21, 2009

Praying for Justice

I read this article a few days ago in the bathroom while I was waiting for the water to get hot and I ended up taking an angry shower. At first it seemed funny – someone stole baby Jesus. No doubt a car of guys riding around and someone had a dare to pay back, or maybe Dr. Williams's "dumb David" was in the car, but whatever the case some idiot got out, ran up to the nativity scene, and jumped into the back seat with Jesus. Haha, ok take it back the next day. But then I read the prayer from the church prayer list. Did you read it? This was printed, size 18 font, on the top of the Daily Break section: "PLEASE PRAY FOR WHOEVER STOLE BABY JESUS FROM THE MANGER AT THE BRITT HOUSE. They've had that baby Jesus for 25 years. Pray that whoever has it experiences such guilt and dis-ease that they have to take it back to get relief." Kristin Davis obviously saw the irony: she highlighted that the request sat alongside soldiers and cancer patients on the prayer list. Is it right for them to pray for the "guilt and dis-ease" of the perpetrator? Or, larger, is it right, ever, for any reason, to pray for the guilt and dis-ease of anyone?

The irony of the Jesus figurine: Jesus had his life for 33 years and prayed, "forgive them, they don't know what they are doing" for the people who took it. The Britts had a piece-of-plastic baby Jesus figurine for 25 years and prayed, "bring them guilt and dis-ease" for the people who took it.

As an aside, it does smack a little of the birth of a relic doesn't it? That some object loosely connected to something holy grows in sanctity year by year, until after 1000 years it is nearly God itself, worthy of worship, pilgrimage, and awe. Today a cheap figurine, 25 years out something to be prayed about for return, 1000 years out… what?

Clearly the Britts were wronged, but what should we say about their reaction? Or how should they react if the boys were caught and they had the chance to press charges? And how should we react in similar circumstances?

A few propositions:

We should always love seeing Justice itself demonstrated, and never love seeing someone punished.
I heard someone a while ago say, "I really like seeing people brought to justice." I wonder if he would include himself? Or his son? Justice is immutable – it is giving what is due. Reward for righteousness is justice; punishment for wrong is also justice. So if we take delight in seeing justice bring pain down on someone's head, we must delight only in the first half: seeing justice. We must not delight seeing pain being brought down on someone's head. The only way Hell can bring God glory is if Justice is demonstrated in it, or some other virtues. The ultimate destruction of any of God's creation, especially that only piece made in his image, cannot bring him glory in itself because it does not represent any essential part of him. Justice does. This might seem a little hair-splitting but I think it's the difference between smug satisfaction in seeing someone "get their due" (a horrible and callusing attitude), and a distraught and weeping exaltation in God's commitment to himself, shown in someone "getting their due."

We should pray for Justice on a criminal only for a demonstration of justice and for the criminal's good.
We should delight in seeing Justice because we are seeing God in it. We should delight in seeing Justice because Justice can reform a person, and we should pray for God to use it to reform. We must not delight in seeing Justice because it returns our beloved baby Jesus figurine to our beloved and ancient (25 years!) nativity scene. We must not delight in seeing Justice because it brings pain down on the head of that guy who, for whatever reason, we feel satisfied to see in pain.

We should never pray imprecatory prayers, or pray them very carefully for Justice's sake alone.
We should not follow the Psalmist in praying, "Blessed shall he be who takes your little ones and dashes them against the rock!" (Ps. 137.9). Or with Isaiah: "Prepare a place to slaughter his children for the sins of their ancestors" (14.21). Or: "O God, break the teeth in their mouths; tear out the fangs of the young lions, O Lord! Let them vanish like water that runs away; when he aims his arrows, let them be blunted. Let them be like the snail that dissolves into slime, like the stillborn child who never sees the sun" (Ps. 58.6-8). The only possible way these prayers cannot be poison from the darkest corners of human depravity is if they are, somehow, aimed not at the destruction of the subjects described, but at the vindication of God's justice and goodness over his creatures' depravity. That is, if depravity has gotten so bad in the world (that, by the way, God made and sustains) that the only way to vindicate God's goodness is to destroy the depraved people, then only then can I see how such prayers could at all be construed as right. If we pray anything at all like these biblical prayers, we should stop and repent. The only way (that I can see) that we could rightly pray any prayer one-tenth as brutal as these is if we had an ultimate, eschatological, abstract love for the vindication and display of God's Justice and Goodness.

If the only real consequence of your being wronged is your own pain, absorb it and use it to imagine the pain Jesus wrongly felt. If some other consequence is at stake (the dignity of your daughter, the safety of the public), bring pain on the head of the criminal only as far as necessary and take no delight in his pain. And above all, love Justice because it is of God.

Publishing from MS Word

You can publish blog posts from MS Word 2007, and it's pretty sweet. Really helps with editing. Like major.

Here are the steps to do it:

  1. Open a new doc in MS Word 2007 (click the MS symbol > New > New Blog Post).
  2. Register the blog host (Blogger).
  3. For Pannenberg you have to use my gmail creds, so email me for them if you want to do this.
  4. Right now I'm using no image host… haven't figured that out yet.
  5. In MS Word, create your blog post, the hit Publish.
  6. See the swankness.

Some formatting experiments:

This text should be small caps.

Footnote¹

This text should be Garamond.


 


 

    

¹How does this look??

Thursday, October 15, 2009

The Terrifying Joy of a Naked Soul

My meditation over the last week has been on 'the glory of a naked soul.' Now, I've said 'soul,' but I don't want to turn immediately inward; first, I want to observe our society's fascination with physical nakedness. Nakedness,in our cultural context, is not neutral. The sight of a naked body inevitably prompts one of three negative responses (sometimes these emotions converge at the same time): 1) laughter: a man streaking across a baseball diamond, a college student sprinting nude through a dorm strike us as hilarious; 2) shame: if someone has walked in on you as you're using the washroom or opened your bedroom door as you are changing, you immediately feel a nearly incomparable susceptibility, and grab whatever objects that lie near-at-hand to cover your exposed flesh; or 3) lust: craving what we do not have, we're tempted to satiate filthy passions by viewing bare portraits. By these illustrations I mean to show that something is not altogether right with bodily exposure, with being fully open to the eyes of another. This is particularly true of one who has a blemish, a birth defect, an out-of-the-ordinary feature--you can be sure that he will not parade this casually before the eyes of others. There is security in our covering--our clothes deflect the gaze of those who would ridicule our physical weaknesses. There is one positive possibility, however, for which I didn't make room previously: delight--seen penultimately in a husband-wife relationship. And we would all want to experience this terrifying joy of being disclosed (with all of our faults) and yet accepted. We laugh and blush and lust not because we don't like the idea, but because it seems impossible. And, in fact, it usually is.

Not only is this true physically, but also psychologically. We robe ourselves in intellectualism, or amiability, or silence to shield 'the actual' (who we are really) from the knowing observation of others. Perhaps, even if we would like to be open, we're not sure ourselves of who we 'actually' are. 'Am I who I am presently or who I hope to become?' We're lost in the layers of idealism. And so, life is a sick game in which we don these garments so that no one sees us and we don't see them--yet all the while dreaming of a setting in which we could experience the terrifying joy of being fully disclosed (with all of our faults) and yet accepted.

Oh how we desire this frightening delight of complete and unashamed exposure! But we loathe it as much as we long for it--for the vulnerability which nakedness (of body and soul) requires is often too frightening a proposition for us to make the leap. So, we need a situation in which we can have both then, right? A relationship in which we can be naked and vulnerable and also clothed and safe. And this is why I love the gospel so much, for it gives me both.

Hebrews 4:13 says, 'And no creature is hidden from his sight, but all are naked and exposed to the eyes of him to whom we must give account.' So here is the terror: there is One who see with 'eyes of blazing fire' which burn to my core; his eyes incinerate fronts and facades and veneers, past games, and past idealism. We know well what he will find: blemishes, filth. So, where's the cover? What will deflect the all-knowing, unrelenting gaze of Holiness? Nothing but Holiness itself. St. Paul writes: 'I count everything as loss because of the surpassing worth of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord. For his sake I have suffered the loss of all things and count them as rubbish, in order that I may gain Christ and be found in him, not having a righteousness of my own that comes from the law, but that which comes through faith in Christ, the righteousness from God that depends on faith' (Phil 3:8-9). Clothed in Holiness, the gaze of Holiness is justly diverted.

This is the terrifying joy of a naked soul. You are bare and yet clothed; you have cause to feel shame and yet cause to feel secure; cause to be paralyzed in fear and yet cause to be exuberantly happy. Love it, Christian.

Sunday, October 4, 2009

Racial Diversity

Why haven't I ever been a part of a racially diverse church? Or am I missing something?

Friday, October 2, 2009

Honest Bodies

Which more truly shows the true state of humanity: a young, nubile (word of the day thanks to WD), healthy, blossoming body or an old, decrepit, diseased, decomposing body? Thank God for old people and their honest bodies that tell us the true state of humanity. If we had only a mirror we would have no reason not to believe that all humanity was gaining strength everyday and that, at this rate, all humans will be gods in a hundred thousand years.

"Remember your creator in the days of your youth, before the days of trouble come and the years approach when you will say, 'I find no pleasure in them.'"

Monday, September 21, 2009

Drinking God's Goodness

"The ax is already at the root of the trees, and every tree that does not produce good fruit will be cut down and thrown into the fire." (Matt 3.10) This is God's pronouncement through John the prophet. But what right does God have to demand fruitfulness of us? How can God look at us, pictured as plants, and demand that we grow fruit? It's like Jesus walking up the fig tree and finding no fruit and cursing it on the spot (Matt 21.18-19). That story has always been a little disturbing. Is it any less disturbing that God threatens to cut us down and burn us if we don't produce good fruit?

Yes, it's disturbing. It's disturbing to say that God has the right to demand of us whatever he will. He is God, we are his creation. "Let us get this one thing straight. God can do anything he damn well pleases, including damn well. And if it pleases him to damn, then it is done, ipso facto, well. God's activity is what it is. There isn't anything else. Without it there would be no being, including human beings presuming to judge the Creator of everything that is." (Virginia Owens)

But I've been noticing lately another reason God has the right to demand fruitfulness of us. And that is this: we've been drinking his goodness our whole lives.

"Land that drinks in the rain often falling on it and that produces a crop useful to those for whom it is farmed receives the blessing of God. But land that produces thorns and thistles is worthless and is in danger of being cursed. In the end it will be burned." - Heb 6.7-8

This is really a remarkable picture for us. There is a field, and there are various plants in this field. The farmer waters the field. The water falls on all the plants equally. The farmer comes to the fully grown plants and finds that some tomato vines have used the water to make tomatos. But lots of other plants have been very happy to drink up the farmer's water, but they have made thorns.

God pours out his grace on both the righteous and unrighteous (Matt 5.45). But not everyone returns to God what his grace deserves. His grace deserves fruit "of repentance" (Matt 3.8), "good" fruit (Matt 7.19), fruit of the kingdom of God (Matt 21.43), fruit that's not like "the cares of the world and the deceitfulness of riches and the desires for other things" (Mk 4.19), fruit that comes from being joined with Jesus (Jn 15.4,5), and fruit that proves you are a disciple of Jesus (Jn 15.8). We must answer the question, "What does this fruit actually look like?" but for right now I just want to say this: whatever it is, you do not want to be found without it. God has commanded us, and that's enough. But we have also, for our whole lives, been drinking in God's sun, God's rain, God's nature, God's able bodies, God's families, God's people, God's words, God's mercy, God's money, God's safety, God's house, God's wife (some of us), God's education, God's food, God's job, God's health, God's music, God's logic, God's language, God's senses, God's pleasures, God's free country, God's gospel. And would he find us happily lapping up his treasures, very sweely enjoying all his good things, and producing no fruit? We have drunk in the rain often falling on us, and I feel for us particularly it has fallen very very often, and what have we done with it? The rain is free - it is grace and grace is not a payment for fruit - but it will serve to further condemn us if we fail to produce it. A free gift cannot create debt, but it does create shame in the one who has wasted it.

So what is coming out of your life? Because God knows what he has put into it.

There is hope because of God's great patience with us. Here's an obscure little parable I love:

"A man had a fig tree growing in his vineyard, and he went to look for fruit on it but did not find any. So he said to the man who took care of the vineyard, 'For three years now I've been coming to look for fruit on this fig tree and haven't found any. Cut it down! Why should it use up the soil?' 'Sir,' the man replied, 'leave it alone for one more year, and I'll dig around it and fertilize it. If it bears fruit next year, find! If not, then cut it down.'" (Lk 13.6-9)

We are "using the soil"; we are "drinking in the rain"; are we using it to grow fruit?


I recommend one of two things: either start producing fruit, or stop drinking God's goodness.

You have one more year.

"Even though we speak like this, dear friends, we are convinced of better things in your case" (Heb 6.9)


Saturday, September 5, 2009

Monday, August 24, 2009

Happiness

Brothers, I have a confession: I'd like to be happy. My wish is, obviously, built on a couple of presuppositions: 1) I don't think myself currently marked by steady happiness, 2) I think I should be happy, 3) I think happiness is attainable. (Others are contained, but I'll leave off there.) This post isn't a defense of already-reached conclusions. I picture myself like a muddy, half-naked, rain-soaked street urchin with my hand clenched and raised to knock at the door of a great stone castle; through the side-panes of the door I can see a roomful of glad-hearted noblemen feasting at a table laden with delicacies, dressed warmly in rich furs and seated by a blazing fire. Not sure why, but that's the image that came to mind. So, I'm going to draw a rough sketch of what I consider happiness to be and how I think we can go about having (or maybe 'catching' is a better word...) it.

First, I think that happiness is the necessary or inevitable end of a good expectation. By 'good' I mean 'ends which we deem profitable'--certainty doesn't always result in gladness of heart (Ex.: knowing that my sick relative will soon die would give me sadness). How we determine profitability is another discussion. By 'expectation' I mean 'hope'--the future realities of which we are by means of faith certain. So, as a hypothetical proof of my proposition, let's say I get word that someone who I love greatly is returning to me after a long absence; I cannot help but rejoice in that. As for Textual evidence the Apostle Peter immediately comes to mind: 'having not seen [Jesus] you believe in him and are filled with an inexpressible and glorious joy, for you are receiving the goal of your faith: the salvation of your souls'. The believer's certainty about Christ--and particularly the progressive consummation of their belief--must end in joy.

Second, the measure of our happiness is directly proportional to the perceived value of the thing for which we hope. If you say, 'I'll give you a candy bar tomorrow,' I'll be excited, to be sure. Not nearly so much, however, as if you promised me an all-expense-paid trip to North Africa.

Finally, and arguing in reverse fashion, if we would have happiness we should aim at faith. Lewis said (thanks for sending this to me, David): 'Aim at this world and you'll miss it. Aim at the next and you'll get it and this world thrown in.' This is true of happiness as well. If we make temporal gladness our ambition, we'll likely miss it and damn our souls in the process.


Ten thousand little trails run off each propositional highway. These three are kind of a condensation of my explorations though. Run with me down a few of the paths, if you'd like...

Saturday, August 22, 2009

Politics

We never talk about politics. My discussions with my parents have gotten increasingly political over the past 2 years, but it mostly stays in-house. Strange... we're in a comparatively highly-educated group, yet we don't talk about politics.
It's true that until recently I've had a quazi-Amish attitude toward politics: do what you want; just don't bother me. Coming to appreciate the "two-cities" analogy for Christian citizenship (cf. Chaucer's London and Canterbury) has convinced me the Amish way is out. No hats, barns, or laissez-faire political attitude; we have responsibilities here because we are really citizens.

So in the spirit of good citizenship let me tee up some free speech and see if anyone wants to free speech back.

After watching CNN's "God's Warriors" tonight I am convinced that democracy must die. Democracy is a provisional cure for disagreement. Ultimately we cannot and will not reconcile fundamental differences through discussion, as if our difference of opinion lies in one of us not having quite all the information. That's all discussion can bring: further information (in any form - relationship, scientific data, personal data, clarification of logic, etc.). Continuing democracy indefinitely is an admission of stifled progress. Democracy is a set of rules whereby we can live with people with whom we disagree. It is a proviso for a schoolyard sounded by conflicting reports about which game will be played b all. The sound reaches such a pitch that a compromised is agreed upon, not to determine the game, but to prevent violence. Areas are set up for groups to play this game or that, but the games all interfere and it would certainly be better if we all played at the same game? This is not the ideal is it? And what will finally remedy? Progress demands democracy die. If we all agree, then democracy dies from lack of need. If we all don't agree, progress demands the death of democracy. Will we go on like this forever?

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

... and from Eric Lehner

Hey guys, here's an article from Prof. Lehner on paper writing. I asked him the same questions I asked Nate plus a few more. Sorry for the formatting... blogger doesn't have the best editor.

How to Pick Your Topic:
  1. Pick a topic of personal interest; if you don’t you will bore yourself with the project and find yourself unmotivated.
  2. Pick a topic approved by professor; if you don’t you might be taking on a topic beyond the scope of what is deemed appropriate for the class.
  3. Pick a topic of considerable difficulty; if you don’t, you will learn little and earn a grade that reflects it.
  4. Pick a topic involving a level of controversy or tension; if you don’t, you will have little at your disposal to energize composition at the analytical level. It is critical that a graduate level paper move beyond reporting information to the level of analysis.
  5. Pick a topic in which there is at least a some degree of existing knowledge; if you tackle a topic about which you have no knowledge whatsoever, you might be biting off more than you can chew.
  6. Pick a topic for which there is sufficient available resources; if you don’t, then you might be forced to abandon your topic later in the semester and start again.
  7. Pick a topic which is or can be sufficiently narrowed
  8. Pick a topic as early as possible

Where to Start Your Research:

  1. The first step is to build a select bibliography. These should be (1) sources of the highest caliber and (2) sources you intend to consult. Do not build a bibliography of the first sources you can lay your hands on. Instead, identify the most significant scholars in the field most relevant to your topic. The course bibliography should be of some help; if not, ask your professor. Once you are able to identify the key scholars and their sources, take note the sources that they consider to be the most valuable, and integrate them into your bibliography. As you build your bibliography, take into account the following:

    - Organization of sources: Use a organization system such as notecards, or a bibiliographic software package such as Citation or Endnote.

    - Credibility of sources: Choose sources of academic credibility; if in doubt, consult your prof.; pay particular attention to the author rather than the title.

    - Usability of sources: Make sure they have an index or a very detailed table of contents.

    - Variety of source types: Don’t consult only books; periodicals and reference works should also be consulted as they often provide valuable specialized treatments.

    - Date of sources: The date of your material says whether or not you are interacting with current thought on the subject.

    - Number of sources: 1 to 1.5 per page of text

    - Sources to include in bibliography: Do not “pad” the bibliography; include sources that you consulted and which contributed to your understanding of the subject.

    - Utilization of sources: Do not expect all the sources to be equally beneficial; 1/4 to 1/3 of your sources will probably function as your main sources, the rest will be minor. Do not build the bulk of the paper on only one or two sources.

    - Perspective of sources: The bibliography should reflect a variety of perspectives.

  2. The second step is strategic reading.

    - Create a list of the top five terms (names of important people, concepts, events) associated with your topic. This is just a starting point; as your understanding of the topic develops, you will not need to follow this procedure rigidly.

    - Prioritize the order in which you will work through the sources you have selected. A suggested approach would be

    ~ Begin with the basic sources first: survey your sources and divide them; divide the general from the specific, the surveys from the technical, the easy reads from the difficult. Read the general, survey, and otherwise easy materials first in order to firm up a foundational understanding of the subject.

    ~ Second, consult the most significant authors in the field.

    ~ Third, consult the remaining sources

    - Consult the index of each of books for the appearance of the key terms in the book. For electronic documents, conduct searches of the occurrence of the terms. For works without an index, you will need to skim read.

  3. The third step is to begin a master outline. This will reflect all of your thoughts on the subject: every thought that you wish to explore, as well as every thought that you have found in your research. It should be updated on a daily basis, from the day you pick your topic until the day you turn the paper in. This outline is the ‘garden’ of your paper: it is here that you will ‘grow’ the argument of your paper and the organization of it. As the analogy suggests, the more you feed and water it, the more fruit you’ll pick from it.





How to take notes while reading:

  1. Take useful notes: this means you need to be purposeful in the kinds of notes you take. If you don’t, the note will not be useful later on. Good notes will:

    - Recognize excellent forms of argumentation on the part of an author. Be particularly attentive to lines of evidence in support of or against a particular position, and assess them for their soundness. Spend the majority of your efforts in this kind of analytical reading, and as little as possible in the attending ‘factoids’ of the subject. When you must discuss these, make sure they are necessary to the development of your subject.

    - Summarize the key thoughts of another author in your own words. You should be able to summarize this in your own words, without plagiarizing. If you are not sure whether or not you are plagiarizing, or you do not know how to rephrase and summarize the thought of another author, consult one of the sources listed in the ‘additional reading’ section.

    - Remember that you can take different kinds of notes for different purposes:

    ~ location notes: tells the writer where to go to revisit a significant paragraph

    ~ quotation notes: the actual verbatim representation of another author (be careful to keep in context)

    ~ restatement notes: representation of an author’s idea with the writer’s wording and sentence structure

    ~ original notes: the student’s record of his own observation(s)

    - Links your notes to their sources: nothing is as perplexing as having a great note and forgetting where you got it from!

What is the best order to follow in the paper writing process?

  1. The order of writing should always be determined by whether or not you have something in mind worth remembering. If you have something worthwhile in mind, write it down. If not, read until you do; then write more. At the end of your day, update your master outline.

  2. 2 things to avoid as you write:

    - Don’t be a slave to your outline; if your research takes you in a direction not anticipated, then adjust your outline. Remember, the outline is simply a reflection of your idea of what the paper will look like. The more you learn, the more your picture of the paper will change. That means that the outline will constantly be changing, especially in the early stages. The research is the master, and the outline is the servant, not the other way around.

    - Don’t do all your reading, then all your writing. The reason why note taking is so critical along the way is that most students don’t have photographic memories, and thus they forget some of the best thoughts that they have had.

On Writing a Paper Against the Position of a Professor


  1. It is generally not advisable to write a paper against the position of a professor without communicating your intent to do so beforehand. Beyond that, it is generally considered courteous to secure the permission — and advice — of the professor before doing so.

  2. A paper that is critical of a professor’s position will normally be scrutinized more closely, and graded more critically, than other papers. For that reason, it is critical that such a paper

    - Accurately represent your professor’s position; failure in this area will make the paper guilty of creating a straw man of your prof’s position. An error of this kind will be very costly.

    - Accurately represent and interact with your professor’s line of argumentation; failure in this area will make your line of argumentation irrelevant.

  3. Interact with what your professor considers to be the key sources on the issue; failure in this area will also render your line of argumentation irrelevant.

  4. Subject your conclusion to the scrutiny of a third party who is sympathetic to the position of the professor. This may give you an unexpected glimpse of how your professor might respond.

  5. Compare your arguments with a guide to logical fallacies as an extra measure to ensure that they are clear of faulty argumentation.
A Couple of Thoughts for Reducing Stress and Improving Results:


  1. By far, the most helpful thing that a writer can do is to start early and visit the paper often throughout the course of the semester. If you want the paper to present a penetrating analysis, it will take time for your thoughts to mature; thus the paper should be viewed as a semester-long project, not a week-long or a weekend-long project. This will help create the extra time needed at the end of the project for putting the paper in proper form and for proofreading.

  2. Make the most of automated computer functions, such as macros (helpful for creating special spacing and for switching from one language font to another rapidly), generating table of contents, generating bibliographies and footnotes, etc. These are huge time savers.
Additional Reading:

  1. Tim Dowley and Beth Wright, eds. “A Short Guide to Writing Research Papers on the History of Christianity” in Introduction to the History of Christianity, CD-ROM (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2006).

  2. Henry A. Virkler, A Christian's Guide to Critical Thinking (Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson, 1993)

  3. Gordon Fee, New Testament Exegesis, 2nd ed. (Philadelphia: Westminster/John Knox, 1993); see p. 57 for Fee’s advice on using quotations.

  4. Turabian, Kate L. A Manual For Writers, 7th ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago, 2007). This edition of Turabian has for the first time, included as a part of the book, a complete 128 page guide to writing research papers, adapted from The Craft of Research, by Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, and Joseph M. Williams. This is perhaps the single most valuable summarization of paper writing strategy in print today.

  5. “Academic Integrity” in Ph.D. in Theological Studies: Handbook for Participants (Deerfield, IL: Trinity International University, 2005), 22-25. This portion provides an excellent summary of what does and does not constitute plagiarism. It may be viewed in its entirety online at: http://www.tiu.edu/files/divinity/academics/phd-ths0506hdbk.pdf